Contact us:

specializing in wedding, birthday and other custom cakes in pittsburgh. 

(PA) 412-714-4937

(WV) 304-670-1856

​In Addition to servicing local couples, we are proud to serve couples who live outside of the Pittsburgh region. Whether it be a meeting place for families or a childhood home, Pittsburgh is a beautiful place to host a wedding.  We have worked long distance with couples from several states across the country and helped them create a magnificent wedding cake for their Pittsburgh wedding.  We are also happy to provide "On the Go" tastings for our out of town clients when visiting the Pittsburgh area.

Mixed With Love Cake & Cookie Co. on Borrowed & Blue

*Photo complements of Chase Images.

Contact us today with any questions you may have or to schedule your tasting and save your date!

For more reviews, visit our testimonial page!

"Mixed with Love can offer not only an amazing product and service, but a delicious sweet addition to your wedding day. Her cakes and treats are amazing, and her professionalism is above and beyond. Mixed with Love is a more personal option for your wedding cake needs, and she put lots of LOVE and attention into every confection she creates . I would highly recommend Mixed with Love for your cake and cookie needs."                                                                                                      - Nicole B., Your Big Day Bridal Services

"Janelle was great from the start. We lived states away from our wedding location of Pittsburgh and while traveling there for work, Janelle provided my husband with a variety of cupcakes to bring home so we got to experience a cake-tasting. Thoughtout the whole process Janelle was conforming to our ideas, while providing many options along the way. Delivery and set up was flawless and she worked wonderfully with our busy schedules. The cupcakes were delicious and our guests loved them. We ordered extra on purpose, and everyone was excited to take some home with them because they were so delicious. I highly recommend Janelle!"  
                                                 - Melissa A., Goldsboro, NC​
 

​​For couples near and far, when ordering your wedding cake, at least 3 month’s notice is recommended, but the more notice, the better. Orders with less notice may still be accommodated. Due to the fact that our reservations are limited, dates do fill up quickly. We suggest contacting us as soon as possible to save your date. Dates are reserved with a down payment of at least 50% of the total amount due, along with a signed Cake Agreement and are non-refundable. The down payment is non-refundable because this date is dedicated and reserved for you.  All orders must be paid in full at least 7 days prior to the delivery date. Small changes may be made to your design and servings up to 1 week prior to your wedding date.  


Still need a little more convincing? We'll let our clients tell you why you should reserve Mixed with Love Cake & Cookie Co. for your upcoming wedding.                                                                          

Wedding Cakes


We know how important your wedding is and we want work with you to create your dream wedding cake. We will meet with you for a complementary 1-hour wedding cake tasting and design consultation. At the tasting, you will get to sample a variety of cake, filling and frosting flavors. We will also go over the design you envision and provide a sketch of your cake after the consultation, if necessary. For more information on our cake tastings, please click here

At Mixed with Love Cake & Cookie Co., we put so much love into your cake, that we only accept limited number of wedding or custom cakes per day. This really sets us apart from others in the industry! We limit the number of cakes we accept, to ensure that your cake is made fresh and gets the full attention it deserves. This also allows us to provide you with excellent customer service. We will work with your florist if you want to incorporate fresh flowers into your wedding cake design. We will also coordinate with your venue to schedule delivery and set-up of your cake, allowing you to have one less worry on your wedding day.


The price of a wedding cake depends on multiple factors, such as number of servings, fondant designs, intricate buttercream piping, and sugar flowers, just to name a few. Our wedding cake prices begin at $3.25 per slice for a buttercream cake and $4.75 per serving for a fondant cake. Our clients, on average, spend approximately $450.00 - $600.00 on their wedding cake.